If you walk a creek bed or a plowed field anywhere in Chenango County, you're going to pick up stones. Most of them are gray. A few aren't. This is a plain guide to what you're most likely holding, written by someone who turns over a lot of creek rock around Smyrna.
One honest note first: I'm a collector, not a geologist. Rock ID from a photo or a single look is a best guess. If a stone really matters to you, take it to a rock club or a college geology department.
Why our stones look the way they do
Two things shaped what you find here.
The bedrock. Under Chenango County is layered sedimentary rock from the Devonian period, roughly 360 to 400 million years old. It formed from mud and sand settling in an old shallow sea. That's why so much of the local rock breaks into flat, gray slabs.
The glaciers. During the last ice age, glaciers dragged stones down from the north and left them scattered across the hills and valleys. So mixed in with the local gray rock you'll find harder, rounder, more colorful cobbles that started out somewhere else entirely.
The stones you'll find most often
Shale and siltstone
Dark gray to brownish, fine-grained, and they split into thin flat pieces. Shale feels smooth and crumbles at the edges. Siltstone is a little grittier and tougher. These are the flat skipping stones that line most local creeks.
Sandstone
Gray, tan, or greenish, and it feels like fine sandpaper. Look close and you can see the sand grains. A lot of old stone walls and foundations around here were built from it.
Fossils in the gray rock
This is the fun part. Because the bedrock formed in a sea, the shale and sandstone sometimes carry fossils. The common ones are brachiopods (little ribbed shells that look like clams), crinoid stems (they look like stacks of tiny coins or beads), and sometimes coral. Split a flat piece of shale along its layers and check both faces.
Glacial cobbles: granite, gneiss, and quartzite
The rounded stones that don't match anything else are often glacial travelers. Granite is speckled with pink, white, and black grains. Gneiss looks similar but has stripes or bands. Quartzite is very hard, often white, pink, or tan, and feels glassy when it's wet. If a stone is round, heavy, and much harder than the gray rock around it, it probably rode in on the ice.
Quartz
Milky white veins and chunks show up in creek gravel. True clear quartz crystals are rarer here than people hope. The famous "Herkimer diamonds" come from a different rock in Herkimer County, not from our creeks.
Simple ways to tell them apart
- Wet it. Color and pattern show up much better wet. Carry a water bottle or just look at stones in the creek.
- Scratch test. Quartz and quartzite will scratch glass. Shale and most sandstone won't. Use an old jar, not your windows.
- Look at the grains. Visible mixed-color crystals usually mean granite or gneiss. Visible sand means sandstone. No visible grains and it splits flat usually means shale.
- Check the shape. Flat and broken is usually local. Round and smooth has often traveled, either by water or by ice.
Where to look, and the rules
Creek gravel bars after the water drops, plowed field edges in spring, and road cuts are the best spots. Always ask before going on private land, and stay well back from road traffic and steep cuts. Rules for collecting on state land and parks vary, and some places don't allow it at all, so check the rules for the exact spot before you take anything home. Take a little, leave the rest, and never dig into creek banks.
Keep a record
Write down where and when you found each stone. A year from now you won't remember, and the location is half the story. Our Rock & Mineral Field Journal is a printable log built for exactly that. The Beginner Rockhounding Guide covers more of upstate NY, and the Stones collection has the creek-found pieces I've wrapped and polished so far.
Happy hunting. Turn them all over.